Pauline Rutter

Excerpt from "The Impossible Landscape"

Pauline Rutter is an artist and researcher based in West Sussex.  Her background in fine art, education, sustainability and activism show up in her academic and creative writing published online by The Centre for Race, Education and Decoloniality Leeds Beckett University, The Culture Capital Exchange and The University of Oxford, Wytham Woods. She has also contributed to the Writing Our Legacy ‘Covert’ Literary Magazine Edition 2.  In 2020 Pauline was the Artist in Residence for the Adur and Worthing Council Climate Assembly and has since  continued to develop creative writing and poetry in response to the ongoing Adur rewilding initiative. Pauline's practice is evolving through her current History PhD which centres Black Feminist Historiography, collective wisdom, and an intersectional, embodied praxis. This has also informed her development of ‘The Black Living Archive’ collaborative project and installation shown at ONCA gallery Brighton. Pauline holds degrees in Fine Art and in Education, a Master’s in International Business Management and an Advanced Diploma in Environmental Management. She continues to write about the pathways seeded by our perceptions of history, community, equity and climate and environmental justice.

 

Website link 

https://uk.linkedin.com/in/pauline-rutter-5642079

 

Social media handle 

Instagram: @pauline.rutter

 

Pauline was one of the Covert Talent Development participants for 2022-23. This piece was published in Covert Issue 3 -- buy the magazine in print for £10 or digital for £5 from our online shop.

Published in Covert Issue 3

The Impossible Landscape

Prologue

To be a Black woman, a brown woman, a woman of colour can be to exist without temporal separation from the past or future. What is certain is that nothing is fixed. There is the equal possibility of breathing into the deep geological past or of dreaming into the contours of a climatologically stressed future. A body finds stillness in the present, but the spirit might wander into a scene playing out over four hundred years ago in the same location. It may follow a stream of consciousness that flows into one future scenario. This poetic fiction leaves space for the multiplicity of living and being. There are questions to be puzzled over and speculative stories to be considered, threads that are woven together in tension if not intentionally. 

 

Part I

There, between the sweet chestnut trees, just beyond the path out of sight from where a tilting car is stilled, there is a woman lying bare. A brown woman lying naked. There is a brown naked woman lying silently among the trees, unmoving beyond the path, unrevealed to Cissbury Ring above. Channels of afternoon sunlight spill into the clearing through generous spaces left by an oak for the beech and by the beech for a hawthorn. They keep their distance, watchful of her belly-ripened crown and taut skin rising gently as if reaching for the canopy. She is unmoving, though the motion of a warm breeze through the branches echoes the ebb and flow of her untethered thoughts, bending but unyielding. Soon she is drifting. 

Her attention is snagged by a memory replaying in slow motion. It is a yesterday from her childhood. She is heading home from school, finally released from the measured chants of times-tables at wooden desks. Her socks have slipped down from her knees unnoticed, as she weaves between the camouflage of rowan, ash, and willow clinging to the bank along the alleyway. She pushes on and on, cardigan unbuttoned and face stinging with the slap of each ragged spur. 

Another memory now finds her sobbing over the shrunken body of her dying father. His watch lies ticking in the palm of her hand. He'd asked the time but had not lingered for her response. 

Five past three. 

Had she sat there all night? 

This memory has unshackled itself from the sanitised hospital room and tightly tucked bed where he lies dying. It is slipping away from the day, away from the months, the years, the name, the face, the very resistance to her life adrift. 

A long exhale returns her to the forest. Her fingernails burrow deeper into the coolness of mossy earth. Damp flesh and bone become soil and bracken. 

Surrender your body to the forest without fight or confrontation or despair.

These words came to her in another dream, she thinks: a night spent negotiating with an impossible landscape for her life and that of the unborn child. Is that enough?  

The hunt for a missing foremother’s foremother, no name or evidence choked up. Is that enough?  

The unborn child is listening for the promise of a warm brown smile. He turns over playfully in his amniotic sphere undamaged. Is that enough? 

She does not swallow the bile rising up  her throat, salty from a million drownings carried on the tide of her history. Is that enough? 

There will be a price to pay for claiming this body, a sacrifice to be made. She will pay the price unflinchingly.

Submit. 

The wind gets up, stroking her stilled torso. It whispers across the forest floor then rises with force to bend saplings low and bows still lower. It lambastes the white chalk exposed on the cliff edge that is forming in her mind. It is not forgiving. It is the back-breaking of the wretched. It wants her to howl along. 

She will not.  

She turns her head to the left and then slowly to the right, her anxious gaze now pleading to the encircling trees. Beneath them she can see the shallow imprints of where others who fell into sadness have lain. All that now remains of bodies and trees alike are upturned roots and decimated stumps not quite dead. Their uneasy rest is not what she seeks.

Aroused now, she replays having pulled up by the roadside and followed step after step through this domain of clumps, coppice, and broadleaves. Did she even know the parts she would have to play in this story?

A shadow had called her through the thicket over root and fern and fungus to this clearing of drier leaves, undisturbed until she stepped in. What was this coming? At first, she acted out the stiffness of solid trunks, all edgy but not quite paralysed. Then softening into purpose, began her simple preparations. Shoes slipped off, red smock unbuttoned, shaken loose, and folded. The lightness of her soles willing her on. Three steps, seven steps, and one more to the centre. At once arriving on the mark unsheathed and ready for the deeds to come. There would be an unravelling if not a surrender.

First there was a lowering to the ground with a gentle release of tension eased by gravity. Recall how her long neck extends, head tipped way back, and legs without the full weight of muscle, liberated from the positive, the negative, the pinching of flesh and a groaning heart. How the moment overcomes her. The roar of blood in her head and rushing of air full into her lungs agitates every sinew. A whisper comes through the trees, 

- There’s a place in the world for you. -

The words wedge between the components of her body separating each part from the whole. She wriggles to free the kaleidoscope of multiplying fragments. Leg and ear, nipple and elbow, hand and womb sliding apart, skin shedding, muscle fibre peeling from each limb. 

The moment has come. The child deep inside is kicking with anticipation. The negative imprint of his small foot pushes her belly egg-shaped, then retracts mischievously. One hand strokes where he has pushed and circles clockwise with four fingers, smoothing out the deformed surface. It then slides further down to feel the ridges and troughs of her ripening body. The other hand caresses where the top of her stomach has settled, expectant of the child’s head that might push up and up as if her mouth were an exit. A third hand is grubbing at loose soil to her left,while another is mirroring this motion at her right flank. Two eyes are shut. Two eyes widen to drink in the swirling of the forest floor. Other eyes inside are resting, behind their lids as the pinks, purples, and blues of a perfect sunset traverse an uneasy sky. 

Yes, this is the moment.

 

PART II

The breeze has changed direction and swept a wisp of herself out of time and place, to a kink in the fabric of this story over five hundred years in the weaving. Immediately the airborne spirit thread is swallowed whole by a song-risen skylark hovering above the path that courses over the South Downs to the coast. You or I might call it Monarchs Way, but in this turbulent century of the Interregnum it is little more than a chalky mud track nestled between field and forest. 

The young figure below her, damp with the sweat of desperate flight, stumbles this way and that, head half-turned backwards to glimpse if his pursuers are still following. He’s been running for almost six weeks and is in poor shape. His black hair matted in places, is ragged around his ears where it was hacked away by a loyal servant. From her bird’s eye view, he is no more than a shabby farm labourer, staggering through the mud in his splattered leather doublet, loose green breeches and tattered jump coat. The finery he discarded some six hundred miles back is just a hint of a memory as he nears the end of his escape route through a countryside he would be king of. 

The wind has dropped momentarily making space for a new voice. To you or I, what is heard fanning out from the small, feathered body following on from above, is a pleasing peep and chirrupy twitter dissolving across the landscape. The young man, however, catches a tender voice drifting down over his sodden leather hat. 

The voice begins. 

- Where am I? -

He cowers, startled by the sound, and only cautiously peers out from under the hat. There is no youthfulness left in his crumpled expression.. This question has tormented him all the way from the bloody Worcester battlefield. Just forty nights since he’d bolted to escape the stench of warm September’s death. Shaken and companionless, he had taken this path growing frailer and more anxious with each step. 

He did not answer the skylark’s question, though he recognised the glint on the grey November skyline as surely the English Channel. Soon he would be at the coast and sailing away from Western Sussex to safety. 

Still the skylark spirit continues undeterred. 

- Who are you hurrying along the way? - she asks.

Again, he does not respond. It is a dangerous and impertinent question to ask the last remnants of an English monarchy, hounded by Cromwell’s New Model Army, lost in the sorrow of an executed father’s headless body on the Whitehall scaffold. This will not be his fate. With each lumpen step he comes closer to a coal ship ready to carry him from Shoreham to France.

- Who are you? - the voice comes again. 

This time he spins full circle to locate the questioner, then freezes on the spot to settle what he believes is the voice of paranoia clawing at his thoughts. 

No one, nothing.

As the tension releases, he cranes his head as far back as it will tip and yells to the wide sky above; 

- No more. I will be king. -

He does not see the skylark.

She is alarmed and would fly off to another spot, and yet a new question is forming in her mind, carried from herself four hundred years hence. For now, around and about in every direction, pecking at the fields, perched or gliding above, are dozens, maybe hundreds of her kind, small, motley and feathered. Beyond skylarks, there are lapwings and yellowhammers, linnets and corn buntings, all busily feeding, swooping and gliding or calling to their young. How different this scene is to that she has left, centuries from now, where her sacrificial body is still lying in the forest embrace. What awaits in that future, our present? Empty skies and the cruel silence of desolation, and extinction.

 

Exhale, to purge this absent reality. 

 

Now it comes to the skylark spirit, as clear as the imperial blue sky above. This proclaimed boy king, newly fleeing for his life, will preside ingloriously over the knotting of royal injustice and of enslavement to a world withered by empire. 

She cannot break herself free. History has bound them together. This taut chain between them strangles like four hundred years of iron shackles choking fifteen million wretched bodies. It stings like flesh whipped raw. It is solid like factory chimney stacks, stately homes, and museum collections.

Here is a coronated king whose flourished decrees will set in motion the ravaging centuries of unjust empire. When the once green and pleasant lands turned colonies will feel the imperial bite above and below the soil, the waves, and the very air that is breathed.

Again, she calls to him as he is now familiar to her.

- You! Below! Boy or king. I’m sent with words for you to hear from the grief-stricken days to come. -

And so, she begins.

What is a life on two legs worth,

If it is robbed of a place to walk, or run, or stand still,

Nestled in the purity of freedom?

Not a country, not a kingdom, not a king.

 

What is the life-giving power of a heartbeat or a green shoot worth,

If they are forced to pump and grow degraded by the poison of profit,

Or the trampling of war hungry men?

Not a county, not a country, not an Empire.

 

What’s offered by the warmth of the sun or the tranquillity of a calm sea, 

To any who are carried off to be scorched across generations,

By dehumanising toil and un-nourishing?

Not a palace, not a bower, not a home.

 

Her certainty in these words resonates through every sinew and every cell of every organism that has ever existed. With the frantic thrashing of her wings, each verse rolls out over the Downs, up to Mill Hill, and on to Thundersbarrow. 

The boy king, irritated by these distracting premonitions, imagines only freedom and escape, crossing the grey water, comfort, self-aggrandisement, the mustering of kingly force. Settling his future. 

The skylark is crestfallen. What of the plundered land and stolen lives? What of the secrets of centuries of misery and the misery of centuries of secrets?

What of a boy king’s frivolous charter for, - the buying and selling, bartering and exchange of, for and with any negro slaves, goods, wares and merchandises whatsoever to be vended or found in western Africa? -

The murmurs of her despairing body alight with the setting of the sun. And in that glorious blaze of gold across a wilfully crimson sky, she is revived just long enough for this conclusive offer. Again, she calls:

 

My tale of destruction and restoration

May be re-written as civilization.

And yet you know young King,

What it is to be hunted out of a land,

Have your life stolen from you,

A slapped-down future turned brutal.

While the souls of spiteful victors

Unknown to them, alight with the all-consuming fire.

What’s to become of the rest of us?

 

A king or queen may rain misery down, 

On their empire of woe while pumping it up

To its full powered industry of war and annihilation.

Or could seed the land with a constitution of

Care and kindness,

Emancipation and reform,

Restitution and forgiving.

The strength of peace of mind

And peace of heart

Could make this land anew.

Without a politics of unrelenting hierarchy,

And instead with the power of

Dignified community, belonging and

Respect.

This could be the tale of all time.

 

The words lodge in his mind long enough to anchor themselves to a future memory of the role he could fulfil. Would he be the king who turns the tide on inequity before it has drawn up fully on our present? 

No answer.  

The sails of his waiting ship now billow into view.

Freedom pulls him on alone.

 

Part III

 

The tide has turned again. Just as one ferried a king away from capture, so another, swollen by Anthropocene melt waters, leaves a second spirit fragment near to drowning. It is centuries off from the naked brown woman’s forest embrace. This aqueous spirit is caught by the sluggish green water creeping inland over a drowned coastline. It is a treacherous overswelling. It smothers abandoned dual carriageways, shopping centres, and graveyard detritus. Storm after storm, surge after surge. The loose ground washed away has congealed with pathogens and toxins, effluent and rot, leaving only a viscous ripple where there once flowed rivers:  Arun, Adur, Ouse, and Cuckmere. 

There are sad songs in this slow drowning water, the sickly effervescence recalls. There are memories of men of science, women of protest, policies of mitigation, and alarms ringing out before the silence came. As the spirit ebbs and flows in the ferment,  a slow moving current luls her with a bacterial overture that recalls this bitter Anthropos. Following on, a movement that recounts how radioactive traces coursed through the soil and water from Dungeness. Others tell of countless adaptations, of counted loss and damage, of counties submerged one after another. This is dangerous living, the spirit wisp moans to herself as she folds over and under, shingle, tarmac, concrete, and farmland. She is gasping and gulping at this endarkened ruin of coevolution and symbiogenesis. What’s left nearby but a small colony clinging on to the uplands of Birmingham. This scrap of life is surrounded by an algal coastline and the risen channel seascape of Sussex and Hampshire, Wiltshire, Gloucestershire, and Worcestershire. 

The spirit wisp is caught then released from the slow-moving phytoplankton around the straits of Cardiff. There is no oxygen in these pitiful waters. It is stifling. She cannot breathe. 

This is not a deep ocean drowning of souls whose names were lost to the middle passage. It is the global devastation of salt, herbicide, and pesticide poisoned water.  Beneath it, urbanised ancestral homes and deforestation. As vapour, it has suckled every newborn with particulates, methane, and CO2. All that has survived the suffocation are invading microbial species. 

Still more stories bubble up to the narrow ridge where Monarchs Way once looped back on itself. They tell of monocultures and abandoned heaths. They burble of forgotten wild meadows and babble of calcareous grasslands. Was that the murmur of wetlands and blanket bogs still in the lost dreamtime of fungi and lichens? Are these the disappearing shadows of the grey partridge and turtledove, the tree sparrow, and corn bunting? 

- Who is left to tell these stories to? - the spirit wisp whimpers. 

Not even a morning dew, or a sprinkle of rainfall on the water to offer respite from the solitude. 

Nothing. No one.

What is there left to wait for?

A breeze picks up easing this resignation. It carries with it a sound almost like a voice. There are words thinning out across the water’s surface but all that can be heard is, forgiven…forgiven…forgiven.

A storm is crashing towards land from what a wisp or any spirit would remember as the Atlantic. It has lashing lightning at its head, and soon the current will electrify this murky broth. She catches a memory of all that university cleverness squandered with the atmosphere, and decades of romantic wildlife camerawork and anthropology submerged in the sealed archives. If there is any sprouting and hatching or birthing and tenderness, it has only moments before it is overwhelmed by the ever-rising tides. 

What a world. What a world.

 

Part IV

In that moment the thread that holds the weft and warp of this story together breaks. The fibres slip away from each other, taking the wisps with them into an easy oblivion. As time snaps back into moments, all that remains is a brown naked woman lying silently among the trees.

There in the forest what was eternal becomes nocturnal. The pull and hush of the woman’s breath draws in so deeply that it can hold a thousand years. She heaves her release from the soil, freeing fingers to wriggle, knees to bend, elbows to push, a back to curl, a neck aroused into lifting. She cannot deny the unborn child now in full growl, demanding more nourishment, dancing, singing, and company. Resistant to the politics of isolation that would tear them from the force of this nourishing ecosystem, they rise. Restored to their full purpose of living among us, they rise. Satiated by all the truth of the impossible landscape, they rise. 

For them.

For us all.

It is time to rise.

 

THE END

 

SUPPORT US

DONATE

SHARE WITH US

VOLUNTEER

SHOP